
 09/08/13  Adjusted: 01/10/17  1 file
 Grades 4
Comparing Money Raised
 Description
 Files
What we like about this task
Mathematically:
 Addresses standards: 4.OA.A.1, 4.OA.A.2, and MP.4
 Highlights multiplicative comparison, an important development in multiplicative thinking beginning in grade 4 (4.OA.A.1, 4.OA.A.2)
 Builds meaning for multiplication equations through word problems 4.OA.A); shows how a multiplication equation models a situation (MP.4)
 Uses the same fact family in parts (b) and (c) to highlight different roles of the unknown factors
In the classroom:
 Provides a context that can be acted out in an engaging way
 Allows opportunity for presentation/demonstration of student work (e.g. poster presentation with number strips)

Making the Shifts
How does this task exemplify the instructional Shifts required by CCSSM?
Focus Belongs to the major work of fourth grade Coherence Builds on previous understanding of multiplication as equal groups to multiplication as timesasmuch Rigor^{} Conceptual Understanding: primary in this task
Procedural Skill and Fluency: not targeted in this task
Application: primary in this task 
Task
a. Helen raised $12 for the food bank last year and she raised six times as much money this year. How much money did she raise this year?
b. Sandra raised \$15 for the PTA and Nita raised \$45. How many times as much money did Nita raise as compared to Sandra?
c. Luis raised $45 for the animal shelter, which was 3 times as much money as Anthony raised. How much money did Anthony raise?

Illustrative Mathematics Commentary and Solution
Commentary:
The purpose of this task is for students to solve three comparisons problems that are related by their context but are structurally different. Multiplicative comparison is purposefully excluded from third grade (see 3.OA.A.3 and 3.MD.A.2), making this task appropriate for fourth but not third grade.
In these multiplicative comparison problems, one factor and the product are amounts of money and the other factor represents the number of times bigger one amount is than the other. Sometimes this second factor is called a "scale factor." In part (a), the larger amount (which is the product) is unknown, while in part (b) the scale factor is unknown and in part (c) the smaller amount of money is unknown. Students will study multiplicative comparison problems involving scale factors that are fractions in fifth grade; see 5.NF.B.5. Note that in fourth grade, scale factors must always be bigger than 1, so students often think that "multiplying makes bigger"; however in fifth grade they will see that when the scale factor is less than 1, the product wil actually be smaller than the initial quantity.
Note that the numbers in parts (b) and (c) are related by the fact family $3×15=45$. This allows for a classroom discussion about the different interpretations of the factors in a mutiplicative comparison context.
Solution One: Tape Diagram
a. She raised six times as much money (as shown in the diagram) so she raised $6×12=72$.
Helen raised \$$72$ this year.
b. $?×15=45$ is equivalent to $45÷15=?$
Nita raised $3$ times as much as Sandra.
c. $3×?=45$ is equivalent to $45÷3=?$
Anthony raised \$$15$.
Solution 2: Writing multiplication equations for division problems
a. Helen raised $6×\$12$ this year, so she raised \$$72$ this year.
b. This is a "Number of Groups Unknown" problem. We can represent the question as $?×15=45$ or $45÷15=?$ So Nita raised $3$ times as much money as Sandra.
c. This is a "Group Size Unknown" problem. We can represent the question as $3×?=45$ or $45÷3=?$. So Anthony raised \$$15$.

Additional Thoughts
Multiplicative comparison situations come in several different types. See Table 2 on page 89 of the Standards and page 23 of the progression document, K5 Operations and Alegebraic Thinking.