- 09/08/13 | Adjusted: 08/01/18 | 1 file
- Grades 2
Three Composing/Decomposing Problems
What we like about this task
- Addresses standards: 2.NBT.A and MP.2
- Attends to all three components of the place value system: base-ten units, bundling/unbundling, and positional notation (2.NBT.A)
- Relates concrete quantities and abstract symbols (MP.2)
In the classroom:
- Prompts students to share their developing thinking and understanding
- Uses concrete representations to make the mathematics explicit
- Allows the teacher to check for understanding throughout students' work
This task was designed to include specific features that support access for all students and align to best practice for English Language Learner (ELL) instruction. Go here to learn more about the research behind these supports. This lesson aligns to ELL best practice in the following ways:
- Provides opportunities for students to practice and refine their use of mathematical language.
- Allows for whole class, small group, and paired discussion for the purpose of practicing with mathematical concepts and language.
- Elicits evidence of student thinking both verbally and in written form.
- Includes a mathematical routine that reflects best practices to supporting English Language Learners in accessing mathematical concepts.
- Offers the opportunity for students to act out the problem when the task features complex real-world situations.
Making the Shifts
How does this task exemplify the instructional Shifts required by CCSSM?
Focus Belongs to the major work of second grade Coherence Develops foundations for multi-digit operations Rigor
Conceptual Understanding: primary in this task
Procedural Skill and Fluency: not targeted in this task
Application: not targeted in this task
Some students are working with base-ten blocks.
a. Nina has 3 hundreds, 8 tens, and 23 ones. How many ones would this be?
b. Lamar wants to make the number 261. He has plenty of hundreds blocks and ones blocks to work with, but only 4 tens blocks. His friend Jose said,
You can still make 261 with the blocks you have
Explain how he can.
c. Find at least three different ways to make 124 using hundreds, tens and ones.
Illustrative Mathematics Commentary and Solution
The purpose of this task is to help students understand composing and decomposing ones, tens and hundreds. The task is meant to be used in an instructional setting and would only be appropriate to use if students actually have base-ten blocks on hand. The last two tasks fully engage the notion of composing and decomposing as needed for algorithms for addition and subtraction. Both parts require persistence, as in the Standard for Mathematical Practice 1.
After seeing the first two tasks, students have the ideas needed to start listing possibilities in the third task. the idea of exchanging a ten for ten ones and a hundred for ten tens is needed in order to complete the task.
While some students might try to simply add, others will recognize that $23$ ones is $2$ tens and $3$ ones. When we combine the $2$ tens with the $8$ tens we already have we get $10$ tens, which is one hundred. So we have $3$ hundreds and another hundred and three ones, which is $403$.
- Lamar could use ten ones for each ten-block which he was missing. So instead of $2$ hundreds, $6$ tens and $1$ one as he wanted, he can start with the $2$ hundreds and $4$ tens which he has and then use two sets of ten ones instead of the two more needed tens. Those make $20$ ones, which we add to the $1$ one needed to get $21$ ones. Collecting all of these we get $2$ hundreds, $4$ tens and $21$ ones. There are many possible solutions – for example using $2$ hundreds, $3$ tens and $31$ ones – but the one given is the most likely.
The list of all ways using $1$ hundred is:
- $1$ hundred, $2$ tens, $4$ ones.
- $1$ hundred, $1$ ten, $14$ ones.
- $1$ hundred, $0$ tens, $24$ ones.
The list of all ways not using any hundreds is:
- $12$ tens, $4$ ones.
- $11$ tens, $14$ ones.
- $10$ tens, $24$ ones.
- $9$ tens, $34$ ones.
- $8$ tens, $44$ ones.
- $7$ tens, $54$ ones.
- $6$ tens, $64$ ones.
- $5$ tens, $74$ ones.
- $4$ tens, $84$ ones.
- $3$ tens, $94$ ones.
- $2$ tens, $104$ ones.
- $1$ tens, $114$ ones.
- $124$ ones
To know the list is complete as we make it, we can start with the standard way, namely $1$ hundred, $2$ tens, and $4$ ones, and exchange tens for ones one at a time to get the first list. Then we exchange the hundred for $10$ tens, to get a total of $12$ tens along with $4$ ones. Once again, we can exchange tens for $10$ ones step by step in order to get the second list. Because we cannot use two or more hundreds, these two lists contain all possibilities.
Standard 2.NBT.A.1 begins "understand that the three digits of a three-digit number represent amounts of hundreds, tens, and ones..."
Words like understand, explain, represent, interpret, and recognize should alert the reader that the expectation for that standard or cluster involves understanding.
For more insight into the progression of place value understanding from grades K-5, read pages 1-11 of the progression document K-5 Number and Operations in Base Ten.
When using manipulatives, it is important for the concrete objects to represent the mathematics faithfully. In this case, the blocks faithfully represent the sizes of the base ten units and the way they recursively bundle/unbundle into one another. However, the blocks do not represent the positional notation of the place value system. Nor do they represent the linear sizes of numbers in the hundreds of thousands. Second, it is important always to connect manipulatives to written symbols and methods. In this case, students connect the base ten blocks to written numerals.
For more information on best practices with manipulatives, read page 19 of the Publishers' Criteria.